Back in St. Olaf:

dev - 2004-03-10 15:18:08
you think justin had the looks? what looks? he looked like a cracked-out Sideshow Bob. that Smiley Ohio Guy is a big cunt. he s-u-c-k-s! and i agree with TH regarding Paula Abdul's judging position. she WAS a star, but because of her looks and dancing. definately not because of her vocal abilities. before you sqwak, realize this is coming from a man who owns "Forever Your Girl" on vinyl. i am a Paula fan, but i tells it like it is. she has no right to judge. especially when she is so afraid to be honest. simon is the only one who will be honest, he just peppers it with more negativity.
-------------------------------
Commenting Salad Eating Whore - 2004-03-10 15:49:03
I think that Matt kid has one of the best smiles I have seen in a long time. He can be on my TV every week, I won't complain. The Lisa girl looks like she needs a bath IMO. But my ultimate fave is Jon Peter - I love me some quirky, goofy boys ya know. Woot.

Forgot what else I was gonna say...
-------------------------------
Trinity Sixty-Three - 2004-03-10 18:14:13
Matt has one of the best smiles, he reminds me of Matthew McConaughey. What is frustrating to me about Matthew is that I *know* there is power in those pipes, but he continues to hold back. Remember when Clay first started out? He was timid, then oh my God he just belted out a Frank Sinatra tune and I *knew* that kid was going places. I was really upset that Lisa didn't get through. But we know why. She isn't pretty enough. And that pisses me off. The 13 year olds don't her. The very last girl who sang, who was so cute -- except her dress. We liked her. My husband liked the Omelet turner, George a lot. Everyone else, blech.
-------------------------------